How to Choose the Right Cat Food: A Complete Guide

Quick answer: The best cat food features a named animal protein (like chicken or salmon) as the first ingredient, carries an AAFCO “complete and balanced” statement for your cat’s life stage, and matches your cat’s individual health needs. Look beyond the marketing claims on the front of the bag — the real story is in the ingredient list and guaranteed analysis panel on the back.

Reviewed by Dr. James Chen, DVM — Board Certified in Feline Practice

Meowing Goods is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Walking down the cat food aisle can feel overwhelming. There are hundreds of brands, each one claiming to be the healthiest, most natural, most premium option for your cat. Grain-free, high-protein, raw-inspired, limited ingredient — the buzzwords pile up, and the prices range from a few dollars to small-mortgage territory.

Here’s the good news: choosing great cat food isn’t as complicated as the marketing makes it seem. Once you understand a few key principles — what cats actually need nutritionally, how to read a pet food label, and which claims actually matter — you can make a confident choice without second-guessing yourself at the store.

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about choosing cat food, backed by AAFCO standards and veterinary nutrition science.

Understanding Cat Nutrition Basics

Before you can evaluate any cat food, you need to understand what makes cats unique when it comes to diet.

Cats Are Obligate Carnivores

Unlike dogs (who are omnivores), cats are obligate carnivores. This means their bodies are designed to get nutrition primarily from animal-based protein. According to the Cornell Feline Health Center, cats have specific nutritional requirements that can only be met through animal tissue, including:

• Taurine — An amino acid essential for heart function, vision, and reproduction. Cats cannot synthesize enough taurine on their own and must get it from their diet. Taurine deficiency can lead to serious heart disease (dilated cardiomyopathy) and blindness.
• Arachidonic acid — A fatty acid found only in animal fats that cats need for skin health, kidney function, and reproductive health.
• Vitamin A (preformed) — Cats cannot convert beta-carotene from plants into vitamin A the way humans and dogs can. They need preformed vitamin A from animal sources like liver.
• Niacin — Cats require higher levels of niacin than many other animals and rely on animal-based sources to meet this need.

This is why you’ll never see a veterinary nutritionist recommend a vegan or vegetarian diet for cats. Their biology simply doesn’t support it.

Key Macronutrient Ratios

A healthy adult cat diet should generally contain:

• Protein: At least 26% on a dry matter basis (many premium foods offer 30-40%+)
• Fat: At least 9% on a dry matter basis
• Carbohydrates: Cats have no dietary requirement for carbohydrates, though small amounts are digestible

Kittens need even higher protein (at least 30%) and fat (at least 9%) to support rapid growth. Senior cats may benefit from slightly higher protein to maintain muscle mass, though cats with kidney disease may need controlled protein levels — always consult your vet.

How to Read a Cat Food Label

The label on a bag or can of cat food contains a lot of information, but most of it follows AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) guidelines. Here’s what matters most.

The Ingredient List

Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight before processing. This means the first few ingredients make up the bulk of the food.

What you want to see:

• A named animal protein as the first ingredient (e.g., “chicken,” “salmon,” “turkey”)
• Additional named protein sources in the top five ingredients
• Named fats (e.g., “chicken fat” rather than “animal fat”)
• Natural preservatives like mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) or rosemary extract

What to watch for:

• Generic terms like “meat,” “poultry,” or “animal by-products” — these are vague and could include lower-quality sources
• “Meat meal” isn’t necessarily bad — it’s actually a concentrated protein source — but it should be named (e.g., “chicken meal” not “poultry meal”)
• Long lists of plant-based proteins (corn gluten meal, soy protein, wheat gluten) that inflate the total protein percentage without providing the amino acid profile cats need

The AAFCO Nutritional Adequacy Statement

This is arguably the most important thing on the label. Look for a statement that says something like:

“[Product name] is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Cat Food Nutrient Profiles for [life stage].”

The life stage matters:

• “All life stages” — Meets requirements for kittens and adult cats (safe for any age)
• “Adult maintenance” — Formulated for adult cats only (not appropriate for kittens)
• “Growth and reproduction” — Designed for kittens and pregnant/nursing cats

If the label says “for intermittent or supplemental feeding only” or “not intended as sole nutrition,” the food is not nutritionally complete and should not be your cat’s primary diet. Treats and toppers typically fall into this category.

The Guaranteed Analysis

The guaranteed analysis panel lists the minimum or maximum percentages of key nutrients:

• Crude Protein (min): Higher is generally better for cats. Look for 30%+ in dry food.
• Crude Fat (min): Provides essential fatty acids and energy. 10-20% is typical.
• Crude Fiber (max): Moderate fiber (2-5%) supports digestion. High fiber may indicate fillers.
• Moisture (max): Wet food is typically 75-82%. Dry food is usually 10-12%.

Keep in mind that you can’t directly compare wet and dry food percentages without converting to a dry matter basis, since wet food contains much more water.

Wet Food vs. Dry Food: Which Is Better?

This is one of the most common questions we get, and the honest answer is: it depends on your cat.

Wet Food Advantages

• Higher moisture content (75-82%) — Cats evolved to get most of their water from prey. Many cats on a dry-food-only diet live in a state of mild chronic dehydration. Wet food helps support kidney and urinary tract health.
• Higher protein, lower carbohydrates — Wet foods tend to contain more animal protein and fewer carbohydrate fillers than dry foods.
• Better for weight management — The higher water content means your cat feels fuller on fewer calories.
• More palatable for picky eaters — The texture and aroma of wet food appeal to many cats, especially seniors with a diminished sense of smell.

Dry Food Advantages

• Convenience — Doesn’t spoil as quickly, can be left out for free-feeding (though portion control is better for most cats).
• Cost-effective — Generally less expensive per calorie than wet food.
• Dental benefits — Some kibble formulations are designed to help reduce tartar buildup, though the evidence for this is debated among veterinarians.
• Easy to use in puzzle feeders — Dry kibble works well in food puzzle toys that provide mental stimulation.

Our Recommendation

Many veterinarians, including our reviewer Dr. James Chen, recommend a combination of wet and dry food. This gives your cat the hydration benefits of wet food and the convenience and dental-scrubbing potential of dry food. A common approach is to offer wet food as the primary meal (morning and evening) with a small amount of dry food available during the day or used in puzzle feeders.

Choosing Food by Life Stage

Your cat’s nutritional needs change significantly through different stages of life.

Kittens (0-12 Months)

Kittens grow rapidly and need nutrient-dense food with higher protein (minimum 30%) and fat (minimum 9%) than adult cats. Look for foods labeled for “growth” or “all life stages” per AAFCO guidelines. Key nutrients for kittens include DHA for brain and eye development, and high-quality animal proteins for muscle growth.

Feed kittens three to four meals per day up to six months, then transition to twice daily. Your vet can help you determine appropriate portion sizes based on your kitten’s weight and growth rate.

Adult Cats (1-7 Years)

Most adult cats do well on a “maintenance” formula with a strong named protein source and moderate fat content. Indoor cats may benefit from indoor-specific formulas that help with hairball control and calorie management, since indoor cats are less active and more prone to weight gain.

Feed adult cats twice daily at scheduled mealtimes rather than free-feeding, which can lead to obesity. The Association for Pet Obesity Prevention estimates that nearly 60% of cats in the United States are overweight or obese.

Senior Cats (7+ Years)

Senior cats may need higher protein to maintain lean muscle mass, along with joint-supporting nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids and glucosamine. Some senior formulas include antioxidants to support immune function and adjusted phosphorus levels to support kidney health.

If your senior cat has a specific health condition — kidney disease, diabetes, thyroid issues — your vet may recommend a therapeutic diet. Never switch a senior cat to a prescription diet without veterinary guidance.

Common Cat Food Allergens

Food allergies affect a small percentage of cats, but they can cause significant skin problems and digestive issues. The most common food allergens in cats, according to veterinary dermatology studies, include:

1. Beef — The most commonly reported food allergen in cats
2. Fish — Particularly in cats fed fish-based diets for extended periods
3. Dairy — Most adult cats are lactose intolerant
4. Chicken — The second most commonly reported allergen
5. Wheat and corn — Less common than protein allergies but possible

If you suspect a food allergy, work with your vet on a proper elimination diet trial. This typically involves feeding a novel protein (like duck, venison, or rabbit) or a hydrolyzed protein diet for 8-12 weeks. Over-the-counter “limited ingredient” diets are not reliable for allergy diagnosis because of potential cross-contamination during manufacturing.

Red Flags to Watch For

Not all cat food marketing is honest. Here are some red flags that suggest a brand is prioritizing profit over quality:

• “Premium” or “gourmet” with no substance behind it — These terms are not regulated by AAFCO and mean nothing specific about ingredient quality.
• Exotic ingredients for the sake of marketing — Wild boar, kangaroo, and other exotic proteins aren’t inherently better. They’re mostly a branding play (though they can be useful for cats with protein allergies).
• Attacking competitor ingredients without evidence — Brands that rely on fear-mongering about “fillers” or “by-products” rather than explaining what makes their own food good.
• No AAFCO statement — Any legitimate cat food in the U.S. market should carry an AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement.
• Customer service that can’t answer ingredient sourcing questions — Reputable brands can tell you where their ingredients come from and who formulates their recipes.

Expert Tips for Switching Cat Foods

Cats are creatures of habit, and abrupt food changes often lead to vomiting, diarrhea, or outright refusal to eat. Here’s how to switch foods safely:

1. Days 1-2: Mix 25% new food with 75% old food
2. Days 3-4: Mix 50% new food with 50% old food
3. Days 5-6: Mix 75% new food with 25% old food
4. Day 7+: Serve 100% new food

If your cat shows digestive upset at any stage, slow down and spend an extra day or two at that ratio. Some cats — especially those with sensitive stomachs — may need a full two-week transition.

If your cat refuses the new food entirely, try warming it slightly to release aromas, or mix in a small amount of low-sodium chicken broth (make sure it’s onion-free and garlic-free, as both are toxic to cats).

How We Evaluate Cat Food at Meowing Goods

When we review cat food products like the Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor, we evaluate:

1. Ingredient quality — Named protein sources, minimal fillers, transparent sourcing
2. AAFCO compliance — Verified nutritional adequacy statement for the intended life stage
3. Guaranteed analysis — Protein, fat, fiber, and moisture levels compared to category averages
4. Palatability — Real-world acceptance by our testing panel of cats
5. Value — Cost per day of feeding based on manufacturer guidelines
6. Brand transparency — Willingness to share sourcing, manufacturing, and quality control information

Our veterinary reviewer, Dr. James Chen, reviews all nutrition content and food product assessments before publication.

Key Takeaways

• Named animal protein first. The first ingredient should be a specific protein like chicken, turkey, or salmon.
• Check the AAFCO statement. Make sure it says “complete and balanced” for your cat’s life stage.
• Don’t fear the ingredient list. Learn to read it instead of relying on front-of-bag marketing.
• Wet food helps with hydration. Consider incorporating it into your cat’s diet, especially if your cat doesn’t drink much water.
• Match food to life stage. Kittens, adults, and seniors have different nutritional needs.
• Transition slowly. Always switch foods gradually over 7-10 days.
• Consult your vet. Especially for cats with health conditions, allergies, or weight issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should be the first ingredient in cat food?

The first ingredient should be a named animal protein source like chicken, turkey, salmon, or beef — not a generic term like “meat” or “poultry.” Named protein sources tell you exactly what your cat is eating and indicate higher ingredient quality. According to AAFCO labeling rules, ingredients are listed by weight before processing, so the first ingredient makes up the largest portion of the food.

Is wet cat food better than dry cat food?

Neither is universally better — each has advantages. Wet food provides more moisture (around 78%), which supports kidney health and urinary tract function, especially in cats who don’t drink enough water. Dry food is more convenient, less expensive per serving, and can support dental health. Many veterinarians recommend a combination of both. The best choice depends on your cat’s health needs, hydration habits, and preferences.

What does the AAFCO statement on cat food mean?

The AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement tells you whether the food meets minimum nutritional standards for cats. Look for the phrase “complete and balanced” followed by the life stage: “for all life stages,” “for adult maintenance,” or “for growth and reproduction (kittens).” Foods labeled “for intermittent or supplemental feeding only” are not nutritionally complete and should not be your cat’s primary diet.

Should I feed my cat grain-free food?

Not necessarily. Grain-free cat food became popular due to marketing, but grains like rice and oats are generally safe and digestible for cats. Cats are obligate carnivores and need high protein from animal sources, but grains as a secondary ingredient are not harmful for most cats. In fact, some grain-free foods substitute legumes and potatoes, which offer less nutritional value. Consult your vet if you suspect a grain sensitivity.

How much should I feed my cat per day?

Feeding amounts depend on your cat’s weight, age, activity level, and whether you’re feeding wet food, dry food, or both. A general guideline for an average 10-pound adult cat is about 200-250 calories per day, but check the feeding guidelines on your specific food’s packaging. Indoor cats and spayed/neutered cats typically need fewer calories. Your vet can help calculate the ideal amount based on your cat’s body condition score.

Can I mix different brands of cat food?

Yes, mixing brands is generally fine as long as each food is AAFCO-certified as complete and balanced. Some cat owners rotate between two or three brands to provide variety and reduce the risk of developing a sensitivity to any single protein source. If you switch foods, transition gradually over 7-10 days by mixing increasing amounts of the new food with the old to prevent digestive upset.

What ingredients should I avoid in cat food?

Watch out for artificial preservatives like BHA, BHT, and ethoxyquin; artificial colors and flavors (cats don’t care about food color); excessive carbohydrate fillers like corn gluten meal as a primary protein source; and unnamed protein sources like “meat by-products” or “animal digest.” Also avoid foods where sugar or salt appears high on the ingredient list. These aren’t necessarily dangerous, but they indicate lower quality formulations.

Is expensive cat food always better than budget brands?

Not always, but price often correlates with ingredient quality. Premium brands tend to use named protein sources, fewer fillers, and better quality control processes. However, some mid-priced foods offer excellent nutrition without the premium markup. The most important thing is to check the AAFCO statement, read the ingredient list, and look at the guaranteed analysis rather than judging solely by price.

Sources

1. AAFCO Pet Food Labeling Guide
2. Cornell Feline Health Center — Feeding Your Cat
3. AVMA — Pet Nutrition
4. AAFP and AAHA Nutritional Assessment Guidelines
5. Tufts Veterinary Nutrition Service